Top 10 Best Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Brands 2017

Best Jar Alfredo Sauce Brand

If you are in a hurry, or you just want something a little different for dinner, then you may want to pick up a couple of jars of the best store-bought alfredo sauce. Did you know that the alfredo dish came from a chef that wanted to make a salty dish for his pregnant wife who was stricken with morning sickness? Down the road, a couple from America on their honeymoon loved the dish so much that they asked for the recipe and brought it home.

Today, two restaurants in Italy claim to have a gift from the couple, a golden fork and spoon, showing that they are the true originator of pasta with alfredo sauce. You can have this dish in your home tonight with a quick trip to the store to pick up one of our the best jar alfredo sauce picks.

Best Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Brand Comparison Table

ProductPhotoTypeCheck Price
The Only Original Alfredo SauceThe Only Original Alfredo SauceReady for use Check Price
Bertolli Alfredo SauceBertolli Alfredo SauceReady for use Check Price
Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real BaconPrego Alfredo Sauce with Real BaconReady for use Check Price
Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta SauceMario Batali Alfredo Pasta SauceReady for use Check Price
Barilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta SauceBarilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta SauceReady for use Check Price
Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo SauceClassico Asiago Romano Alfredo SauceReady for use Check Price
McCormick Cream Garlic Alfredo Sauce MixMcCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Pasta Sauce BlendDry mix for preparing sauce Check Price
Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo SauceStonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta SauceReady for use Check Price
Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce MixKnorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce MixDry mix for preparing sauce Check Price
Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce Simply Organic Alfredo Seasoning MixDry mix for preparing sauce Check Price
If you are still unsure about which product may be right for you after looking at the comparison table above, read on to find the best alfredo sauce brand right for you.

 

Best Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Brand Reviews

The Only Original Alfredo Sauce – Best Classic Taste

The Only Original Alfredo SauceWhen you want creamy, cheesy goodness, then we suggest that you try the Only Original Alfredo Sauce. The sauce manufacturer says that this alfredo sauce has more parmesan cheese than any of the rest.

If you have an allergy to milk, then you will not want to use this sauce as it contains real dairy. If you want a single serving, then you can use this option for several meals. This item must be in the refrigerator after opening.

Whether you want to put together a meal for the whole family, or you just want a creamy sauce for a solo meal, the Only Original Alfredo Sauce may be what you crave. One thing that I like the most about the sauce is that it helps you make a quick meal in about 15 minutes.


Pros
  • Use and store container
  • Easy to recognize packaging
  • Full of cheese
Cons
  • We find no disadvantages with this alfredo sauce brand

Bertolli Alfredo Sauce – Best Pick for Traditional Flavor

Bertolli Alfredo SauceBertolli is a name that people connect with quality and taste. Tradition is another thing that may come to mind when you hear the name. With ingredients like aged parmesan cheese, romano cheese, and fresh cream, you may find that this sauce is your go-to favorite for busy weeknights, long weekends, or those times when you just want something salty and filling.

The glass jar that houses the Bertolli Alfredo Sauce keeps the ingredients fresh and makes it easier to get out of the container. You may recognize the bright red label in the shape of an oval with the big, white Bertolli name on the front of the jar when you are shopping. The green ribbon above the label says since 1865 making it easy to know you have the top alfredo sauce pick.

If you are a fan of aged cheese, then this brand might become a regular for you. The thick, creamy texture is often something chefs bring up when leaving a note about the product. We like to keep a few jars in our pantry – just in case.
Pros
  • Fresh, quality ingredients
  • Easy to spot label
  • Popular brand
  • Easy to store and tote
Cons
  • We see no problems other than it goes too fast

Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real Bacon – Best Sauce with Bacon Pick

Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real BaconWe love bacon! If you do too, then you may want to get a jar of Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real Bacon. This sauce might be just the thing when you want something different for lunch, or you need dinner with a little pizzazz. Many people recognize the brand for a long time pasta sauce war with Ragu.

The slender jar that the Prego Savory Bacon sauce comes in will fit nicely in the refrigerator door once you open it. You may like that the glass bottle retains the freshness of the ingredients and lets you see the pieces of bacon inside. You can quickly find the sauce in the grocery store by looking for the real bacon label.

Since Alfredo sauce is so versatile, you can easily use one of our top brands like the Prego with Bacon to put together a hearty meal in minutes. We like using the penne pasta with a side salad and breadsticks to round out the meal. You can add any vegetable and meat combo you like though.
Pros
  • Brand name
  • Quality ingredients
  • Real bacon
  • Easy storage
Cons
  • We found no issues with this sauce or brand

Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce – Best Famous Sauce Pick

Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta SauceMost know the name Mario Batali from the famous Iron Chef series. This product uses quality ingredients like fresh cream to give the sauce an authentic flavor. If you are a fan of the champion, then you may want to pick up a couple of jars of Mario Batali Alfredo Pasta Sauce the next time you are shopping.

Having jars of sauce like this on hand makes it much easier to put a quick dinner together when you are juggling sports and school schedules along with work. We think this classic sauce is a great pantry item for your busy days.

You may find that you like this sauce best with a meat and vegetable like chicken and broccoli. The ingredients round out the meal with the dairy in the sauce, so it is a complete choice for the days when you are spent from cramming for finals or working on a difficult proposal at work.

This pick is our best famous sauce because of the name and the quality of the product. We think you will likely try this ingredient and want to use it often.
Pros
  • Quality
  • Accessibility
  • Convenience
Cons
  • We find no flaws with this sauce

Barilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta Sauce – Best Recognizable Brand Pick

Barilla Creamy Alfredo Pasta SauceWhen many think of pasta, the first name that comes to mind is Barilla. Whether you plan to use fettuccine noodles or jumbo shells, the pasta sauce is a creamy blend that works with any pasta dish you want to make. You may find that this sauce is a good staple to have in your pantry for the times when company unexpectedly shows up, and you want to serve them a hearty meal.

When you want pasta, but not the tomato sauce, alfredo sauce is a white sauce that is much milder than spaghetti sauce. With real ingredients like cream and Romano and Parmesan cheeses, this sauce is a great addition to a dinner party or family gathering. You will likely notice the jar in the pasta aisle because of the classic blue label with red oval and white lettering saying Barilla.

Many buyers felt that this sauce had a proportional amount of salt versus other alfredo sauces on the market. The consistency is a plus with this sauce being thicker than some brands.

Barilla Creamy Alfredo Sauce is a keeper. We like it because it is such a household name. It is easy to use too.
Pros
  • Quality ingredients
  • Balanced flavor profile
  • Number one sauce brand in Italy
Cons
  • As a popular brand, the Barilla Alfredo Sauce may not be easy to find on grocery shelves

Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce – Best Signature Recipe Pick

Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo SauceWhen you want a creamy pasta dish without all the calories, then you may want to consider adding this product to your list. The sauce has 65 percent less fat and over 50 percent fewer calories than traditional alfredo sauces on the market.

You may recognize the yellow and blue Classico label. If not, look for the white, block letters of the name, a blue ribbon that says light, and a white label with the cheeses. When you are trying to stick to your diet, but want something healthy and hearty, this sauce can be a great alternative to standard alfredo sauces.

This sauce is easy to use in any pasta recipe.
Pros
  • Healthy option
  • Signature recipe
  • More than one cheese in the sauce
Cons
  • The sauce never lasts long enough

McCormick Cream Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix – Best Sauce Packet Pick

McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Pasta Sauce BlendDo you wish you had a sauce mix on hand that was easy to store? McCormick makes a packet of Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix that you can put in the cupboard or spice drawer. This packet is easy to make with a little butter and milk. Simply melt the butter, and then add the milk and sauce packet. Serve the sauce on fettuccine or your favorite pasta.

The McCormick sauce packet is a great way to plan ahead for those days when you get home from work late and still want a hearty meal. With no MSG, there is no need to worry about additives you do not want in your food. All natural spices and flavors give this dry mix an authentic flavor.

When you need a sauce mix you can store in the pantry; then this packet may be just what you want. You may or may not like the garlic flavor, so it is best to sample this dish at least once before making for a party or family function.

McCormick makes several sauces and spice blends that you can store in a drawer. This sauce mix is super convenient. You can even take it with you to a friend’s house and make it after you arrive without the need to tote glass jars.
Pros
  • Convenient package
  • No refrigeration necessary
  • No flavor enhancers
Cons
  • The sauce has garlic flavoring, so you cannot adjust the taste to your wishes so easily

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Sauce – Best Specialty Sauce Pick

Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Pasta SauceDo you tend to look for unique items in the grocery store? Are you the type of person that chooses sauces with different additives or flavor profiles? If so, then our best specialty sauce may be right up your alley. The Stonewall Kitchen makes specialty food items like Basil Alfredo Sauce that gives you a fresh take on the classic flavor.

You can easily store this sauce in the cupboard and add it to freshly made pasta for a surprisingly bright dish. This sauce is a great addition to a chicken pizza or bruschetta as well. Just look for the green and white label that has the delicate scrollwork on the bottom.

The Stonewall Kitchen sauces are part of a signature line of products created for fairs and farmer’s markets that have grown over the past 20 years. The sauce is an award-winning food option given the outstanding product designation on three occasions.

You may find that this sauce is too good to share. Keeping a few bottles in your pantry is a great way to surprise dinner guests with a tasty dish.
Pros
  • Unique taste
  • Specialty blend
  • Versatile sauce
  • Convenient size
Cons
  • There is never enough to go around

Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix – Best Powder Mix Pick

Knorr Alfredo Pasta Sauce MixDo you like Alfredo Sauce so much that you always keep some in your cabinet or refrigerator? We do too! The Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix comes in a handy canister that holds 16 ounces. You will recognize the Knorr name immediately in the pasta aisle. The classic handwritten name in white against the green and red label is easy to find on store shelves.

Are you looking for delicious food items that you can use in your emergency stockpile? We think this alfredo sauce mix is a good item to have in your kit because all it needs is a little milk and butter. If the power goes out, then these items are the first thing on your list to use up when it is going to be off for a long time.
When you want a sauce mix that you can use and stick back in the cabinet, then you might want to purchase the Knorr Alfredo Sauce Mix in a can because it makes a bunch. You can feed a party with the amount of sauce this mix makes.


Pros
  • Easy to store
  • Makes more than a gallon of sauce
  • Same recipe as the Knorr packets
Cons
  • Requires milk and butter to reconstitute

Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce – Best Organic Pick

Simply Organic Alfredo Seasoning MixWhen you are picky about what your family eats, then you want to be sure to buy products like the Simply Organic Sauce Mixes. The Alfredo Sauce packet is a certified organic product that you can store in your cabinet until you need it.

The Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce packet weighs less than an ounce and a half so that you can store it practically anywhere in the kitchen. The mix uses organic seasonings. A portion of the purchase price goes to organic farming establishments.
When you want your family to eat as healthy as possible, then this sauce mix is a great option. The certified organic label means that you know what you are paying for with this mix.
Pros
  • Convenient packaging
  • Natural ingredients
  • Thick and creamy when made
Cons
  • Requires additional ingredients like milk to make

Best Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Brand Buyer’s Guide

When you want a satisfying dinner choice, pasta is an excellent option because you can pair it with so many ingredients. Alfredo sauce gives consumers the opportunity to mix up dinner choices like spaghetti or chicken Parmesan with a lighter option. This buyer’s guide discusses some of the differences between the best jar alfredo sauce brands on our list.

Best Jar Alfredo Sauce Brand
How to Choose the Best Jar Alfredo Sauce Brand

Flavor profile – creamy and fair, or robust and bursting with flavor

Bertolli and Barilla Alfredo Sauces are traditional brands that offer the classic flavor you expect from a white gravy. When you want a stronger taste that enhances the meat or vegetables you add to the dish, then you may want to go with the McCormick Creamy Garlic Alfredo Sauce Mix. We suggest you keep a variety of alfredo sauces on hand for all the cravings you get.

Powder versus fresh alfredo sauce

This choice depends on whether you are set on fresh foods, or you want to store a product for times when you have a hankering for something creamy and cheesy. Our favorite fresh sauce is a toss-up between the Only Original Alfredo Sauce and the Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce. Both use fresh cheeses and cream. The Only Original brand comes in a refrigerator tub where you can use the sauce by the serving for one person or more.

Powder packets and canisters give you the option to keep the refrigerator free while providing a base for a thick, creamy pasta sauce that you can use at any meal. We like the powder as a pantry staple. The choice between the McCormick Creamy Alfredo Sauce and the Knorr Classic Alfredo Sauce Mix is one you will have to let us know which one you pick because frankly, we CANNOT choose. Because that’s just a matter of taste.

Healthy options for better homemade meals

  • Organic: – Simply Organic Alfredo Sauce
  • Light: – Classico Asiago Romano Alfredo Sauce

Flavorful options ready for meat and veggies

The Prego Alfredo Sauce with Real Bacon is obviously top on our list of tasty options because, well BACON! One of our favorite picks to add chicken and some broccoli to is the Stonewall Kitchen Basil Alfredo Sauce on top of a bed of jumbo pasta or penne. We also think this a great sauce for making white pizzas. You may come up with a lot more ideas once you try this alfredo sauce pick.

No matter which pasta sauce you decide to try first, we are sure that at least a few of the best store bought alfredo sauce picks are going to end up in your kitchen. We like the versatility of the light flavor, the creaminess, and of course, the CHEESE! Fresh ingredients, easy storage, and BACON, well no more explanation is necessary with bacon. The best thing is that you can have a ton of fun trying out the sauces with family and friends.

Conclusion

We chose to use several types of alfredo sauce mixes on our list because it gives you versatility. You can select an item that stores well in the pantry or a powder mix that never needs refrigerating after opening. Our list includes natural and organic options for even the most health-conscious buyers. If you like alfredo sauce, then we are sure that you will find a few of the ones we list as suitable options for your pantry.

One thought on “Top 10 Best Store-Bought Alfredo Sauce Brands 2017

  1. Hellen says:

    What an interesting selection. I used to cook this sauce myself before I tried The Only Original Alfredo Sauce. Although I cook well, the sauce from the store seems to taste more delicious than my own. Since then, I do not prepare it, I just buy it. After this review, I think I’ll try a few more options.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *